rixmith wrote: Since it looks like mischiefmaker is retiring (viewtopic.php?f=7&t=27122), your survey may not be so interim after all... Best of luck to mm and thanks for all the hard work on this in the past
Frailezim wrote: Thanks for attempting this OP. A few constructive criticisms though. Can you randomize the list in any way? As you will get design bias listing the characters in order based on previous versions. Is there a way to create a blank list 1-x and make the names drop and drag from a cloud in some way? What would also be interesting is to see ownership of said listed characters. Is there the opportunity to add a follow on question. There are a few angles to take on this, as if I had to list characters I own and consider the best Black Widow would be top ten easily. Especially if you consider her power in PVE. Maybe you should put this on hold and get some feedback on your design?
thedude wrote: I realise its not perfect, and only 29 people have completed at this point anyway so I doubt I'll do it again, but I won't be offended if anyone wants to set up a better alternative.
udonomefoo wrote: thedude wrote: I realise its not perfect, and only 29 people have completed at this point anyway so I doubt I'll do it again, but I won't be offended if anyone wants to set up a better alternative. I went in to do it, but realized my opinion doesn't really count since I'm still low in the 2-3 transition. I haven't even played with more than half of the characters on the list when fully covered so I can't really help.
morph3us wrote: Thanks for putting in the effort. It's actually getting harder to rank the characters objectively now that there are so many of them, particularly once you get beyond the top 5 or 10. They seem to sit more in "bands" than precise rankings, where a group of characters are at about the same power level.
raisinbman wrote: Kingpin: B/C - So Kingpin's graphics, sprites, and abilites are all really flavorful, but in actual gameplay he's not that great. I mean, he's not terrible, but unless we get a suite a villians that works well with him, I don't see much of his potential. D3 does get points for giving him 3 abilites that make sense and have synergy with each other. Of course, you could pair him with Hood or Iron FIst, but there's not many who CANT pair with Hood or Iron Fist.
ronin-san wrote: raisinbman wrote: Kingpin: B/C - So Kingpin's graphics, sprites, and abilites are all really flavorful, but in actual gameplay he's not that great. I mean, he's not terrible, but unless we get a suite a villians that works well with him, I don't see much of his potential. D3 does get points for giving him 3 abilites that make sense and have synergy with each other. Of course, you could pair him with Hood or Iron FIst, but there's not many who CANT pair with Hood or Iron Fist. His black is SIX, man. It has the potential to go off, A LOT. But the problem is that unless you whale up and level him immediately, it'll be months before we have people pairing Doom or IF with him, because of the popularity of XFW.
turul wrote: I think we should suspend this poll until the new changes hit in